MadMax Trade Supply

Home › Guides

Sediment vs carbon whole-house water filters: which do you need?

Which should I buy?

Use a sediment cartridge to catch particles such as sand, silt and rust; it is rated in microns (smaller = finer). Use a carbon cartridge to reduce chlorine taste and odor; Pentair rates its carbon cartridges by gallons of chlorine taste and odor reduction. Many homes use both, with the sediment cartridge first so particles don't clog the carbon. Neither type is a disinfection system: Pentair warns not to use these cartridges with water that is microbiologically unsafe or of unknown quality without adequate disinfection.

Sediment cartridges

Sediment cartridges trap particles. The nominal micron rating is the particle size the maker rates it for; a 1-micron cartridge filters finer than a 25-micron one and loads up sooner on dirty water.

Cartridge (Pentek model)TypeHousingNominal ratingChlorine taste and odor capacity (Pentair)
P25 $19.99SedimentStandard 10"25 micron—
S1 $22.99Sediment (pleated cellulose)Standard 10"20 micron—
DGD-7525 $32.99Sediment (gradient density)Big Blue 10"25 micron—
DGD-2501 $36.99Sediment (gradient density)Big Blue 10"1 micron—
DGD-2501-20 $62.99Sediment (gradient density)Big Blue 20"1 micron—

Carbon cartridges

Carbon cartridges reduce chlorine taste and odor. Granular activated carbon (GAC) cartridges hold loose carbon; carbon block cartridges are bonded carbon and also have a micron rating.

Cartridge (Pentek model)TypeHousingNominal ratingChlorine taste and odor capacity (Pentair)
GAC-10 $32.99Carbon (granular activated)Standard 10"—5,000 gal @ 1.0 gpm
GAC-BB $59.99Carbon (granular activated)Big Blue 10"—12,500 gal @ 2.0 gpm
CBC-10 $37.99Carbon blockStandard 10"0.5 micron>20,000 gal @ 1 gpm
CBC-20 $48.99Carbon blockStandard 20"0.5 micron>45,000 gal @ 2 gpm
CBC-BB $98.99Carbon blockBig Blue 10"0.5 micron>50,000 gal @ 2 gpm
CBC20-BB $155.99Carbon blockBig Blue 20"0.5 micron>150,000 gal @ 4 gpm

Capacities are Pentair's figures at the flow rate shown, based on the maker's own testing (Pentair: not tested or certified by NSF). Pentair lists CBC-10, CBC-20, CBC-BB and CBC-20BB, and GAC-10, as tested and certified by NSF to NSF/ANSI Standard 42 for material requirements only. Pentair also notes that new carbon cartridges can release fine carbon dust and should be flushed after installation.

What the NSF standards cover

NSF/ANSI 42 covers aesthetic effects such as chlorine taste and odor; NSF/ANSI 53 covers health effects. A cartridge certified to Standard 42 for material requirements only is certified for its materials, not for a reduction claim. See NSF's overview of water treatment standards.

Common questions

Do I need a sediment filter before a carbon filter?

It is common: a sediment cartridge in front keeps particles from clogging the carbon. Follow your system maker's setup.

Does a carbon filter remove sediment?

Carbon block cartridges have a micron rating too (Pentair rates CBC at 0.5 micron), but on water with a lot of sediment a separate sediment cartridge in front keeps the carbon from clogging early.

Which micron rating should I buy?

Replace like for like if the old cartridge worked. A finer rating traps smaller particles but fills up sooner on water with a lot of sediment.

Sources

Prices include any sales tax we're required to collect.

Shop water filter cartridges How often to change a whole-house filter Standard vs Big Blue cartridges

Related categories: Under-Sink, RO & Whole-House Filters. General information only; follow the equipment maker's instructions and local codes. Updated 2026-11-14.